Restricted to everyone indefinitely. Restriction lift date: 10000-01-01
Moral shielding: A grounded theory of integrity maintenance in multidisciplinary teams
Loading...
Date
2014
Authors
Deady, Richard
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University College Cork
Published Version
Abstract
Using a classic grounded theory methodology (CGT), this study explores the phenomenon of moral shielding within mental health multidisciplinary teams (MDTS). The study was located within three catchment areas engaged in acute mental health service practice. The main concern identified was the maintenance of a sense of personal integrity during situational binds. Through theoretical sampling thirty two practitioners, including; doctors, nurses, social workers, occupational therapists, counsellors and psychologists, where interviewed face to face. In addition, emergent concepts were identified through observation of MDTs in clinical and research practice. Following a classic grounded theory methodology, data collection and analysis occurred simultaneously. A constant comparative approach was adopted and resulted in the immergence of three sub- core categories; moral abdication, moral hinting and pseudo-compliance. Moral abdication seeks to re-position within an event in order to avoid or deflect the initial obligation to act, it is a strategy used to remove or reduce moral ownership. Moral gauging represents the monitoring of an event with the goal of judging the congruence of personal principles and commitments with that of other practitioners. This strategy is enacted in a bid to seek allies for the support of a given moral position. Pseudo-compliance represents behaviour that hides desired principles and commitments in order to shield them from challenge. This strategy portrays agreement with the dominant position within the MDT, whilst holding a contrary position. It seeks to preserve a reservoir of emotional energy required to maintain a sense of personal integrity. Practitioners who were successful in enacting moral shielding were found to not experience significant emotional distress associated with the phenomenon of moral distress; suggesting that these practitioners had found mechanisms to manage situational binds that threatened their sense of personal integrity.
Description
Keywords
Moral shielding , Moral distress , Multidisciplinary team , Mental Health , Moral abdication , Moral ownership , Pseudo-compliance , Clinical decision-making
Citation
Deady, R. 2014. Moral shielding: A grounded theory of integrity maintenance in multidisciplinary teams. PhD Thesis, University College Cork.