Enforcing (EU) non-discrimination law: Mutual learning between British and Italian labour law?

Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Files
IJCLLIR_28_4_Dagmar_Schiek.pdf(125.97 KB)
Published version
Date
2012
Authors
Schiek, Dagmar
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Kluwer Law International
Published Version
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Abstract
While substantive EU non-discrimination law has been harmonized in great detail, the enforcement regime for EU non-discrimination law consists merely of a few isolated elements. Thus, the pursuit of unity through harmonization in substantive EU law is accompanied by considerable regulatory autonomy for Member States in securing the efficiency of those laws, reflecting the diversity of national enforcement regimes, and resulting in twenty-seven different national models for enforcing discrimination law in labour markets. This article pursues two connected arguments through a comparison of rules for enforcing non-discrimination law in labour markets in Britain and Italy. First, it argues that enforcing non-discrimination law in labour markets is best achieved when responsive governance, repressive regulation and mainstreaming equality law are combined. Second, the article submits that diversity of national legal orders within the EU is not necessarily detrimental, as it offers opportunities for mutual learning across legal systems. The notion of mutual learning across systems is proposed in order to analyse the transnational migration of legal ideas within the EU. Such migration has been criticized in debates about the 'transplantation' of legal concepts or legal irritation through foreign legal ideas, in particular by comparative labour lawyers. However, EU harmonization policies in the field of non-discrimination law aim to impact on national labour laws. The article develops the notion of mutual learning across legal systems in order to establish conditions for transnational migration of legal ideas, and demonstrates the viability of these concepts by applying them to the field of non-discrimination law.
Description
Keywords
EU non-discrimination law , Labour markets , Comparative labour laws , EU harmonization , Non-discrimination law
Citation
Schiek, D. (2012) 'Enforcing (EU) Non-discrimination Law: Mutual Learning between British and Italian Labour Law?', International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 28 (4), pp. 489-511.
Copyright
© 2012. Kluwer Law International BV, The Netherlands.