C.D. Broad on emergence and machresis
Loading...
Files
Accepted Version
Date
2026-10-12
Authors
Walmsley, Joel
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Springer Netherlands
Published Version
Abstract
This paper re-examines C.D. Broad’s theory of emergence with a view to situating it within contemporary debates about emergence and machresis. While Broad’s 1925 account in The Mind and Its Place in Nature lacks an explicit treatment of the causal powers of emergent phenomena, I show that his neglected earlier 1919 paper, “Mechanical Explanation and Its Alternatives,” contains a detailed example of how components may behave differently when organised into higher-level systems. This analysis, I argue, anticipates Carl Gillett’s recent concept of ‘machresis’, according to which composed entities constrain the powers of their components. By reconstructing Broad’s views in this light, I show how his theories can be understood as a form of “supervenience without reducibility.” Moreover, this reconstruction enables a substantive response to standard objections concerning downward causation. I conclude that, taken together, these different elements of Broad’s account, far from being historical curiosities, remain a viable and philosophically fruitful framework for analyzing contemporary cases.
Description
Keywords
C.D. Broad , Downward causation , Emergence , Machresis , Non-reductive physicalism , [SocietyPoliticsEthics]
Citation
Walmsley, J 2026, 'C.D. Broad on emergence and machresis', Synthese, vol. 208, no. 4, 198, pp. 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-026-05845-x
