Does deliberation help deliver informed electorates: Evidence from Irish referendum votes
Loading...
Files
Supplemental Material
Date
2019-12-26
Authors
Suiter, Jane
Reidy, Theresa
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Published Version
Abstract
We argue that integrating citizen deliberation structures into the pre-referendum phase can deliver systematic improvements in democratic outcomes such as alignment between values and vote. Using data from three Irish referendums, the research examines the potential of deliberative mini-publics to deliver more informed electorates. An emerging branch of literature argues that direct and deliberative democracy can be mutually supportive. It demonstrates that there is much potential to be realised when the fields of deliberation and the practice of referendums are brought together. Greater understanding of referendum issues can be achieved by mini-publics extending the time allocated to discussing issues, producing rigorous and informed materials and delivering decisions which stem from citizens who are more likely to approximate the general public and therefore be more trusted by ordinary voters. Ultimately we argue that deliberative processes enhance subjective and objective knowledge and this leads to referendum outcomes where a larger share of voters cast ballots which align with their fundamental values. The analysis demonstrates that there was greater alignment between the core values of voters and their vote decisions when a deliberative phase was introduced into the constitutional referendum process; and furthermore that this alignment grew as deliberation became more embedded and normalised.
Description
Keywords
Referendums , Citizen deliberation , Mini-publics , Abortion , Marriage equality
Citation
Suiter, J. and Reidy, T. (2020)' Does deliberation help deliver informed electorates: Evidence from Irish referendum votes', Representation, 56(4), pp. 539-557. doi: 10.1080/00344893.2019.1704848
Link to publisher’s version
Collections
Copyright
© 2019, McDougall Trust, London. Published by Taylor & Francis. All rights reserved. This is an Accepted Manuscript of an article published by Taylor & Francis in Representation on 26 December 2019, available online: https://doi.org/10.1080/00344893.2019.1704848