Skin cancer excision is more efficient and cost effective in a specialist secondary care service

O'Sullivan, S.; Bowe, S.; O'Riordan, T.; Murphy, Aileen; Murphy, M.; Heffron, C.; Bourke, J. F.

Skin cancer excision is more efficient and cost effective in a specialist secondary care service

Files

Skin-Cancer-Excision-Is-More-Efficient-and-Cost-Effective-in-a-Specialist-Secondary-Care-Service.pdf(408.81 KB)

Published Version

Date

2020-03

Authors

O'Sullivan, S.

Bowe, S.

O'Riordan, T.

Murphy, Aileen

Murphy, M.

Heffron, C.

Bourke, J. F.

Publisher

Irish Medical Organisation

Abstract

Aim: To compare the relative efficiencies of skin excisions in primary and secondary care. Methods: We compared the benign: malignant ratio for specimens referred by General Practice, General Surgery and the Skin Cancer Service to the regional pathology laboratory over one month. We used cost minimization analysis to compare the relative efficiencies of the services. Results: 620 excisions were received: 139 from General Practice, 118 from General Surgery and 363 from the Skin Cancer Service. The number (%) of malignant lesions was 13 (9.4%) from General Practice, 18 (15.2%) from General Surgery and 137 (37.7%) from the Skin Cancer Service. Excision was cheaper in General Practice at €84.58 as compared to €97.49 in the hospital day surgical unit. However, the cost per malignant lesion excised was €1779.80 in general practice versus €381.78 in the Skin Cancer Service. Conclusion: Our results indicate that moving skin cancer treatment to General Practice may result in an excess of benign excisions and therefore be both less efficient and less cost effective.

Keywords

Skin excisions , Primary care , Secondary care , Malignant , Benign

Citation

O’Sullivan, S., Bowe, S., O’Riordan, T., Murphy, A., Murphy, M., Heffron, C. and Bourke, J. F. (2020) ‘Skin cancer excision is more efficient and cost effective in a specialist secondary care service’, Irish Medical Journal, 113(3), P38 (5pp).